Seagate Earnings Power Is Real but Valuation Has Caught Up
PRICE $644.58 | TARGET $625 | RETURN-3.0% | RATING HOLD |
Summary
I downgrade Seagate from Strong Buy to Hold. While operational performance remains impressive, the current valuation increasingly reflects expectations of sustained pricing strength, HAMR adoption, and hyperscaler demand, leaving a narrower margin of safety.
Seagate delivered a strong 1Q financial year 2027, reporting $4.233 billion in revenue, non-GAAP EPS of $7.68, and $1.5 billion in free cash flow. Both revenue and earnings exceeded consensus expectations, with Q2 guidance also coming in ahead of market expectations.
The company's nearline Exabyte shipments increased just 1.5% sequentially, while pricing accounted for a significant portion of $604 million sequential revenue increase. This raises an important question about the sustainability of earnings growth as pricing expectations become increasingly embedded in the valuation.
Mt financial year 2027 financial model points to continued earnings strength, although the current valuation warrants greater caution. The valuation framework establishes a $625 price target, while the full report examining the assumptions, earnings outlook and risks underpinning this assessment.
On December 12th, we will be bringing together investors and long-term thinkers at Fairmont Mt. Kenya Safari Club, Nanyuki for the Annual Henriot Capital Investor’s Summit. A full day of research, markets, meaningful conversations and shared experiences, built around one idea: long-term wealth conversations for future generations. Request an invitation below.
Source: Thinkstock
